Showing posts with label Lagarde. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lagarde. Show all posts

Monday, 12 October 2015

12th October 2015, Greek leftist government’s first austerity bill will be submitted today

·         ECB’s Draghi stated that there should be debt relief after the completion of current evaluation. During his interview to Kathimerini of Sunday, he mentioned that the discussion regarding debt restructuring will occur only after the completion of current review. Draghi represents the third head of Greece’s troika of creditors, who reconfirmed that Greece’s debt structuring is on the table and discussion will start just after the completion of current review.In addition, he emphasized the need that Greece will implement all structural changes which are included in 3rd MoU, in order that local economy will return to growth trajectory.

·         IMF’s Lagarde reconfirmed from Lima - Peru that IMF won’t participate in Greece’s program as long as there is no agreement as regards debt restructuring. She emphasized the need that Greece will implement structural reforms mainly in pension system and banks.

·         Athens International Airport’s CEO, Paraschis was voted as CAPA Airport Chief Executive of the Year 2015. The International Committee of Centre of Aviation valued highly AIA’s innovation, high standard of service vis-a-vis the reduction of operating cost, reduction of carbon footprint, development of the biggest photovoltaic park in an airport, and dynamic marketing strategy.

·          According to press linkages, the EU is planning to merge all Greek Banks’ subsidiaries in Balkan states by end of 2015. This means that in case there are four Greek banks operating in one Balkan state, they will all merge into one Greek bank. At the moment there are about 2,700 branches of Greek Banks in Balkan states with approx. 35,000 employees. As a second step, each subsidiary will be sold within 2016.

·         Greek exports were reduced by -8.9% in August. It is the third consecutive month of exports’ drop. However, Greece’s trade balance deficit also dropped by -8.8% compared to Aug’14. In general, trade balance deficit dropped by -18.5% during the period Jan-Aug (compared to the same period in 2014). This is mainly due to a higher reduction of imports (-9.9%) vs. the reduction of exports (-3.3%).

·         The reduction of value of exports reflects mainly to the drop of price of fuels. On the other hand exports without fuels increased by +6.8% in August (compared to Aug’14). In terms of foreign markets, exports decreased by -22.4% to countries outside EU, and exports to EU region increased by +8.1%.

·         It appears that Greece Ministry of Finance will roll out a massive plan to minimize cash transactions and maximize bank cards’ usage throughout Greek economy. In addition, the use of bankcards will be the sole mean of transactions for a series of professions which were champions of tax evasion such as doctors, lawyers, plumbers, electricians, builders etc.  

Risk assessment. I remain on my previous view that the current coalition SYRIZA – Independent Greeks won’t last long. Despite the fact that Tsipras enjoys a refreshed mandate, the list of structural reforms which are included in the requirements to complete current review, impact vested interests and require broad political support which goes beyond current coalition. Regardless Tsipras verbal determination, it is still doubtful that the current coalition will finally ratify and/or implement those structural reforms. Considering the verbal objection of all other pro Europe political parties to support this austerity bill, we may see coalition’s first losses during next Saturday’s vote.

SYRIZA’s government will submit its first bill with austerity measures today. It appears that there is one MP ‘Independent Greeks’ (SYRIZA’s ally), who has sent ambiguous messages regarding his final stance during the vote of austerity bill. In addition, there is another MP who resigned from Central Committee of SYRIZA, as an act of protest as regards the way that lists of Party’s candidates were formed before elections. If both MPs either abstain or vote against the forthcoming bills, then the austerity bill will be ratified by 153 MPs (out 300).

It appears, that Greece’s government in an effort to meet budget targets, has chosen mainly to raise taxes instead of cutting expenses. In addition, taxation will be increased across all citizens, regardless if they could tax evade or not. It becomes evident that this will result to the increase of citizens’ arrears and social dissatisfaction.

Last but not least, Ministry of Finance’s Alexiadis announced a series of measures, which will reduce cash transactions and increase the bank cards' usage. Greece traditionally is a cash society which means that this is a structural reform of immense importance, which also includes cultural elements; and this makes it even harder to implement.

Thursday, 8 October 2015

8th Oct 2015, Greek stock prices might be heavily undervalued



·         as it was expected Greece’s government won last night's vote of confidence; 155 MPs voted ‘Yes’ and 144 voted ‘No’ (there was an absent MP, who stated that he would vote .

·         France's Hollande stated during his speech at European Parliament that Europe will agree on debt restructuring with Greece, if the latter meets its obligations. It is important to mention that this statement occurred just before the vote of confidence at Greece's Commons and while having Chancellor Merkel sitting next to him. 

·         Ministry of Economy’s Stathakis stated that GDP contraction could be less than -1.5% due to spectacular performance of tourism and less than expected impact of capital controls to local economy. He added that approx. 4.5 bios euros of EU funds will be released by end of 2015.

·         Ministry of Finance’s Alexiadis stated that a new real estate tax will be introduced especially to those Greek citizen who own real estate abroad. He mentioned that Greece will replicate Italy’s similar tax. He added that effective 2016, all real estate transactions will be processed automatically through the so-called system TAXIS. 

·         Ministry of Pensions’ Katrougalos stated that SYRIZA’s government will try to protect all pensions below 1000 euros. At the moment there about 900,000 pensioners who earn more than 1000 euros on a monthly basis. Press linkages show that pensions above 1,000 euros will be reduced between -11% up to -13% (in weighted average terms)

·         Greece’s 10 yr. bonds' yield dropped below 8% (at 7.774%) for the first time since November 2014. This was fluctuating close to 20% in 10th of July 2015. On the other hand, yield of German Bund was fluctuating around 0.6% while Italian at 1.69%, Spanish at 1.83% and Portuguese at 2.35%.

·         Greece’s 2 yr. bonds' yield dropped below 9% (at 8.932%) which represents one year low. As a reminder, the 2 yr.  bonds yield reached the level of 58% in 10th of July 2015.

·         Local Bourse’s index and trading volume increased during the last few days. More specifically, total gains during last week crossed the level of 6% while banks’ index increased by 28.8% during the last four sessions.  In addition, trading volume increased to over 60 mios on Wednesday from just over 40 mios euros on Tuesday

·         There has been an escalation of geopolitical crisis in Syria. More specifically, Russia said it has launched rocket strikes on Islamic State group targets in Syria from warships in Caspian Sea – about 1,500 km (930 miles) away.

Risk assessment. I remain on my previous estimates that the current SYRIZA – Independent Greeks coalition won’t last long. In addition, Greece's GDP contraction will be less than it was initially expected after the implementation of capital controls.
This, among other things, means that Greek stocks' evaluations remain relatively cheap. Since my previous commentary in which I was stating that Greek Banks’ stocks might be cheap, prices increased by almost 30%. The positive thing is that trading volume is gradually catching up as well but still remain low compared to pre-crisis levels.
It appears that the SYRIZA-led government will proceed on implementation of austerity measures. Although the Greek government will have to implement pension cuts and structural reforms, with a marginal majority of 5 MPs, the country’s risk profile has been improved significantly since July because of a) Tsipras’ fresh mandate and b) the vast majority of opposition remains pro-Europe. This is evident mainly on yields of Greek bonds.
Tsipras' determination to complete the evaluation of current program within the agreed timeframe, has nothing to do with the urgency for disbursement of 2 bios euros. This is mainly due to the fact that completion of evaluation will send the positive message to markets, could attract investments. The resulting improvement as regards overall economic environment, will allow him to proceed on Greek Banks’ recapitalisation. And if everything goes well, he could close the deal as regards the Greek debt's restructuring.
You may ask, ‘how can a leftish politician be so sensitive about markets and banks?’ Although Tsipras is very keen to use populistic language to attack markets and banks, it seems that he understands that a failure on recapitalisation front could result to Banks’ bail-in. A potential bail-in won’t only impact bondholders, and depositors but will cause derailment as regards local economy’s recovery and more importantly could cause social unrest.   
In addition, Tsipras has shown evidence in the past that is very cautious as regards developments in banking sector. More specifically, during the recapitalisation of Greek Banks in 2014, which occurred just after his victory in European Parliament, he kept low profile but started pushing for snap just after the completion of recapitalisation (October '14). 
Probabilities of having a positive scenario are high. In addition, what is beyond dispute is that many stocks in Greece are at this point incredibly cheap by almost any measure.
Although trading volume in local Bourse is tiny, it gradually increases. In addition, Banks’ stock prices have been increased by almost 30% since last week of September. Due to capital controls, all purchases of Greek stocks represent foreign funds. If Greece’s government keep its promises and meet its obligations, Athens Stock Exchange could act as the mean for foreign capital inflow to Greek economy.
Few things are as little understood as investing, and rarely are they as misunderstood as when they are most interesting and useful. For all reasons explained above, current prices of Greek stocks represent a typical example of heavily undervalued assets.

Wednesday, 7 October 2015

7th October 2015, Greece’s risk profile has been improved but crisis it ain't over yet

 
·         IMF issued a warning that despite the fact that Greece’s leftish government signed off the 3rd MoU, the risks related to Greek question remain. In addition, it remains in its initial estimates which were showing a GDP contraction of -2.3% in 2015, due to a significant contraction of -5.4% which will occur during Oct-Dec 2015.  

·         Greece’s government submitted in local Commons the budget 2016 bill. It includes increases of taxes and pension cuts which are totalling 4.3 bios euros. The total amount concerning tax increases reach the level of 2.5 bios euros but could be higher considering that the farmers’ bill has not been published yet. 
·         Ministry of Finance’s Alexiadis stated that effective 2016, Greek citizens will stop visiting Tax Offices which has been the standard practice up to now, and represented a source of corruption. This means that all customer requests will be processed either through web or through KEPs (Citizens Service Centers) which are currently servicing a significant part of citizens’ requests.  

·         Ministry of Finance Mardas announced that the local government will implement an existing plan and create a Summer Davos in a Greek island. It will be an Aegean island which will be transformed to a global conference centre and where countries from all over the world, will be invited to ‘adopt’ a building.  

·         It appears that there are three potential buyers of National Bank of Greece’s stake at the Turkish Finansbank. More specifically, the Turkish bank Fibabanka (in cooperation with Societe Generale), Garanti Bank and Qatar National Bank. 

·         The local Council of State decided against the previous government of SYRIZA's decision to partially close down the goldmines of ‘Hellas Gold; hence operations of Hellas Gold restarted. As a reminder, the SYSIZA’s government decided to close down a part of goldmine operations just before September’s parliamentary election, which led the company Hellas Gold’s decision to close down all operations. 
 
·         There was another incident of attack to IRS officers. It occurred in a local religious feast in Northern Greece, where IRS officers found a merchant having an undeclared cashier, which was producing fake receipts for customer transactions. This was the fourth incident of attack to Tax Officers within the last four months.  
 

·         Cyprus is planning to launch a 10 year bond in the coming weeks amid improvement of local economic conditions. Nicosia is planning to raise up to 1.5 bios euros by end of 2015. The announcement came just after the positive evaluation of Cypriot program by its creditors which led to the release of 0.5 bios euros disbursement.   

 
 
Risk Assessment. The Greek crisis aint’t over yet. Leftish Tsipras’ government chose to continue its previous alliance with the extreme right political party of ‘Independent Greeks’ amid deteriorating economic conditions and significant political and economic challenges ahead. I remain on my previous views that a) GDP contraction will be less than was initially expected and b) that the current coalition won’t last long.
Greece’s leftish government will need to handle within the following 5 weeks, three major challenges such as 1) evaluation of current program, 2) recapitalisation of Greek Banks and 3) debt restructuring.  This requires broad political consent which doesn't exist, despite Tsipras' recent mandate. Actually Tsipras has already made some kind of steps to bridge the gap (who has created), between SYRIZA and the other centre, centre-left parties PASOK, Potami and Centrist Union.
The Greek leftish government’s first full-year budget is going to be ratified tonight. It is highly likely that tonight’s vote will be evolved without any losses from the current parliamentary majority. However, implementation risks of austerity measures remain. This is due to the following reasons:
·         Budget 2016 includes a significant number of austerity measures, which are in contrast to the populistic rhetoric that brought Tsipras to power.

·         The new set of austerity measures impacts significant vested interests such as farmers and islanders. It is the first time that farmers loose significant privileges, which allowed them to enjoy an almost tax free status. In addition, the new measures impact significantly all pensioners which earn above 1000 euros on a monthly basis. These pensioners come from powerful state sector and other significant social groups such as engineers, lawyers and doctors.

·         At the same time, there is no relaxation of taxes to the regular, loyalist taxpayers. This creates an explosive mixture which could impact a) the implementation of budget 2016 and b) the current coalition SYRIZA – Independent Greeks.

Wednesday, 30 September 2015

Sep 30th, 2015, Greece needs to run in order to meet its deadlines


·         Tsipras continues his trip in US. He met with representatives of the powerful Greek American community yesterday night. He admitted that US administration was supportive during Greece’s negotiation with its European partners.

·         European Commission’s Vice President Dombrovskis issued a clear warning to Greece’s government that the first review of 3rd MoU must by completed by November 15, 2015.

·         It appears that Greece’s economic contraction due to capital controls will be less than it was initially expected. Press linkages indicate that in 2016 budget’s bill which will be submitted by local Ministry of Finance in coming days, will include a contraction of -1.5% vs. 2.3% which was initially expected.

·         New measures which indicate relaxation of capital controls announced by local Ministry of Finance. According to the new legislative act, those funds which are generated from liquidation of foreign domiciled mutual funds and are deposited to local banking accounts, are exempted from the daily limit of 60 euros; hence depositors could withdraw 10% of those deposits.  

·         According to European Commission, Greece lost 37 bios of revenues related to VAT during 2009-13. Tax evasion remains at significantly high levels; local ministry of finance fails to collect the 35% of revenues related to VAT.

·         In an effort to attract Foreign Direct Investments, Greece’s Confederation of Enterprises (SEV) started discussion with business counterparts of other major economies. More specifically, the president of SEV Fessas was met with the administration of MEDEF in Paris.

·         Turkey’s Financebank announced that its parent company National Bank of Greece (NBG) is considering various ways to meet additional capital requirements. Press linkages indicate that NBG is planning to sell it 99% stake in Finansebank. The expected outcome of this transaction could surpass the level of 2 bios euros which means that NBG could meet its capital requirements after stress tests without asking for additional capital injection.

Risk assessment. It appears that the next three weeks will be the most difficult period for the new Tsipras’ government. This is because the 3rd MoU is frontloading which means that about of 50% of bailout’s measures need to be implemented by mid-October, in order to complete recapitalisation of local banks within 2015. Last but not least, the program review needs to be completed by mid- November.  
Ahead of expectations for better than expected GDP and better than expected state revenues due to excessive use of bank cards (which increases tax collection through VAT), it appears that Greece’s government negotiates with its European partners some kind of relaxation of measures, which seems to be feasible.
However, Greece’s government needs to choose relaxation of taxes vs. relaxation of structural reforms on state’s expenditure i.e. pension system. At the moment, Greece has 3 million pensioners compared to 3.5 million employed citizens. It is absolutely necessary that pension system’s restructuring will proceed in order to increase employment, which will enhance pension system’s sustainability and support 
economic growth.